Salinger

What is J.D. Salinger's deal?  I don't understand how people could consider this guy an even passably good writer.  I read 'Catcher in the Rye' years ago and thought it was mundane drivel.  Made it through a few of the Nine Stories thinking, "Alright, maybe Catcher was crap, but this guy is supposed to be good.  I'll give it another try."  Nada.  Now, for lack of something else, I'm making another fruitless forray into fiction with 'Raise High the Roof Beam, Carpenters'.  More garbage.  Now, I know what you're thinking, "Hey Cavutto, his stuff is supposed to suck.  You wouldn't understand.  You don't get it."  Yeah.  You're probably right.  I don't get how thoughtless crap can be considered good.  It's the literary equivalent of modern 'art'.  A bunch of hacks who couldn't cut it as real artists. 

But then again, I just don't get it

TheJoeD on

I have the exact same opinion of Hemingway. I wanted so bad to like him, but it's so, so dry. I've only tried one book though...ehhh...reading is boring.

TwoStripe on
I too have the same feeling about Hemingway. I dont see it, he sucks. I do like Salinger tho. A Good Day for Bannanafish rules.
Cavutto on
I guess I need to learn how to appreciate the crappier things in life.
TwoStripe on
Its the crappy things that make other crappy things seem less crappy.
Lastexit29 on
i dont think salinger is crappy, you really just dont get it ryan :)
TwoStripe on
I bet Astronomer would get it. Hes one smart guy.
Astronomer on
Cavutto is correct.  J.D. Salinger is a hack.  Short, incomplete sentences with underdeveloped ideas.  That's it.  The characters are lifeless.  Plot is negligible.  I can't read it either.  I just can't.  I wanted to like it.  I just didn't.  Oh well. 
TwoStripe on

I challenge you to a duel!

Paper or plastic?

phoenix on
Agreed on Hemingway.  I've never read Salinger.  I try to avoid classics because more often than not, they suck royal ass.  I read the Wikipedia on Salinger, and decided I'd read enough right there.
bkro9 on

I'm an anti-shakespeare person myself. Same plot reworked each time. Pointless drivel.

I enjoy Salinger and Hemingway though. Sue me.

cavutto
Male - 28 years old
NEWINGTON, CT
United States
Bookmark and Share